Turning Any Occasion into Something Delicious!

ChatGPT Image Oct 5, 2025 at 01_51_10 PM_edited.png

Welcome

Welcome to Out of the Box Baking, A Momma Meyer Company, where creativity and flavor come together in every bite. Based in Slinger, WI, we specialize in custom cakes, cake pops, truffles, and bites, all made from scratch with high-quality ingredients and a personal touch.

Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just craving something sweet, our desserts are designed to make every moment a little more delicious.

Order online for local pickup at The Sippy Hippie, or contact us for delivery and shipping options throughout the Metro Milwaukee area.

What We Do

At Out of the Box Baking, we turn every occasion into something unforgettable. Known for our signature cake pops, we also craft protein bites, chocolate truffles, and custom cakes that are as beautiful as they are delicious.

Every treat can be personalized to match your special event—birthdays, weddings, showers, or corporate gatherings—and we proudly accommodate all dietary needs with gluten-free, vegan, sugar-free, or allergy-friendly options.

From everyday indulgences to one-of-a-kind creations, Out of the Box Bakery is here to make your celebration a little sweeter.

Our Commitment

At Out of the Box Baking, we are committed to creating delightful experiences through our high-quality and delicious treats. We prioritize offering premium selection of sweets, protein bites, chocolate truffles, and custom cakes that bring joy and sweetness to every moment.

Quality Products

Premium Selection

We meticulously source the finest ingredients to create our delicious treats, ensuring top-notch quality and taste that delights our customers.

Customer Satisfaction

Your Happiness Matters

Customer satisfaction is our top priority. We go above and beyond to exceed expectations, meet dietary restrictions and create a positive, memorable experience for everyone we serve.

Community Engagement

Supporting Our Community

We actively engage with our community through local businesses, events, and collaborations, aiming to spread joy and sweetness beyond the walls of our bakery.